There has been recent outrage among the
Relevant Magazine audience about a recent article sent out in Relevant's weekly e-mail: "850 Words". In this article (which you can read by going
here), the author talks about a recent U2 concert she attended in New York where Bono at one point stopped the concert, put on a blindfold that said "Coexist" on it: in which the "C" was an Islamic crescent moon, the "X" was a Star of David, and the "T" was a cross. She writes that he started saying: "Islam, Jew, Jesus, all true" and repeated it over and over as a mantra. She goes on to say that she has idolized this man for his faith and the things he has done, but left feeling like she was "covered in bile" after thinking he is leaning more towards universalism.
Now, it was certainly a bold article... and Relevant has taken notice of the outcry from readers and cast a special addition of their podcast in order to share some of the thoughts that people have sent them and to further the discussion. I encourage you to listen to this podcast - go to the website:
www.relevantmagazine.com, and at the bottom of the page you can listen to it. A lot of people corrected the author - saying that Bono, at his other concerts, has not said, "Islam, Jew, Jesus, all true", but instead said, "Islam, Jew, Jesus. It's true: all sons of Abraham." Now - this points to a song from their newest album entitled
Love and Peace Or Else. A line in the chorus states:
Lay down | Lay down your guns | All you daughters of Zion | All you Abraham's sons. In that context, the coexist portion of the concert seems to be more about gaining peace amongst a situation that has been riddled by hate and judgementalism - not about all of these faiths leading to God.
However, the discussion continues. Check it out and put in your two cents.
I do agree with the author of the article that we have a tendency to idolize these men and women of faith who take a stand for something - Bono, Rob Bell, Donald Miller, Beth Moore, Switchfoot... etc. etc. Putting them on a pedastal is not healthy - for them or for ourselves. I would caution, however, to not try to swing the completely opposite way where we ignore them and their causes for the sake of protecting ourselves. I should not idolize Bono, but I will say that this man and the work he has done for the crisis of AIDS and poverty in Africa is what has opened my eyes to the need and helped me to hear God's heart on the matter more clearly. If I ever were to meet Bono, I would not be able to thank him adequately for sparking the love of God for these people in my heart.
Once you read the article, read this reply (or portion of it) from Steve Stockman who authored the book "Walk On: The Spiritual Journey of U2" -
Just one last thing and I promise I don’t mean it to be a cheap shot. Tara says of this rock concert moment, “It was, without question, the most disturbing experience of my life; I felt like I’d been covered in bile.” We have thousands of children dying because they don’t have the water and drugs that we take for granted. We have three people having more control over wealth than the sixty poorest nations. We have wars raging, some of us involved in the killing of thousands of civilians for the most dubious of reasons. We are raping the creation of our God and Father and it is causing catastrophic “natural” tragedies. In the season when God made himself poor, we are lavishing one another with joke presents and gratifying our sick materialism while people die of hunger. Only 13% of evangelical Christians in America are interested in helping with the HIV/AIDS pandemic in southern Africa. Anti-Christs are rampant and ravaging the world and the most disturbing thing is a mis-quote from a rock star. God forgive us. At least Bono believes He will!